Rosetta, Sydney review

The Rosetta dining room

The Rosetta dining room

Neil Perry’s osteria is a welcome addition to Sydney dining, delivering straight-up Italian food with plenty of sophistication.

Here's a thing: just about every restaurant in Australia does vitello tonnato wrong. Slices of veal topped with a tuna mayonnaise? Do not pass Go, do not collect 200 lire. Tonnato doesn't mean "tuna" - that's "tonno" - it means tuna-like. It's a reference to the preserved-tuna texture the poached veal is supposed to have once it's spent a day or two luxuriating in the sauce. It's not pretty, which is probably why most chefs think they're doing you a favour by reinventing it, but in doing so they're robbing you of the pleasures of its true feel and flavour.

But I've just found someone who gets it right. Who says "contemporary mores be damned" and serves the veal in all its gloopy, faintly fishy splendour, layered with slivers of lemon and a healthy scattering of capers. A thing of joy.

Which tiny backstreet osteria is flying the flag for Piemontese classics? Which nonna is keeping it real? That intimate, 200-seat osteria is called Rosetta, set in the quiet village of Wynyard, and the nonna in question goes by the name of Neil Perry.

Head chef Richard Purdue and Neil Perry

Straight Italian food done well in a handsome setting is hard to find in Sydney. It's surprising, really, when you consider that it's pretty much all half the city wants to eat when it goes out for lunch or dinner. Alessandro Pavoni, Giovanni Pilu and Federico Zanellato, the top-rated Italian-born chefs in the city, remix their traditions with smoke, coconut and kombu. It's not just the new guard, either. Buon Ricordo, that bastion of cucina vera, scatters raw kingfish with crystals made of dehydrated Campari, and there's puffed brown rice on the spatchcock at Lucio's.

It's tasty stuff, to be sure. But what if you don't feel like "textures of mushroom" or "miso-strone"? What if you don't want macadamia nuts in your brodo?

Potato gnocchi with oxtail ragù

Neil Perry has the answer. Having been road-tested thoroughly in Melbourne, Rosetta has landed in Sydney as an instant hit. The business crowd, so thoroughly in thrall to Rockpool Bar & Grill, pack it out, devouring cacciatora-style duck, chicken cooked under a brick, and a very polished eggplant parm at lunch, clinking Spritzes on the terrace over plates of burrata with grilled treviso, and then stepping back inside to split a nice big veal cotoletta on the bone and punch another bottle of Barbaresco for dinner.

This is food that's about satisfaction rather than surprises. Poached artichokes are scattered with almonds, olives and mercifully little else. Baby snapper is grilled whole, coming to the table beautifully juicy, dressed with oregano-fragrant salmoriglio, the salsa Sicilians love to pair with seafood.

Pasta, made in house, is consistently impressive, whether it's twists of strozzapreti swimming in a pungent, powerfully salty sauce of pecorino and pepper, butter-bathed agnolotti plump with roast pheasant, veal and pork, or curls of garganelli and squid in a sauce vibrant with bottarga and tomato.

Burrata, grilled treviso and olive oil

It's easy to spend money at Rosetta. Those pasta dishes mostly hover around the $30 mark for what the waiters describe as an entrée portion. The veal cutlet, served with a cheek of lemon, a tuft of rocket and a smile is $49. The wine list offers plenty of choice in the $100 a bottle and up department, and I've been charged $21 for a glass of Lucido catarratto, an eminently drinkable and versatile white from Sicilian producer Marco De Bartoli. It retails for $35 a bottle.

But it's mostly money well spent. The place looks a million dollars - a modern, boisterous, glamorous beast of a thing, glinting with gold highlights, marble and timber, staggered over three levels thrown open to plenty of glass. There's roughly 36,000 staff on the floor and the Rockpool veterans among them actually know what they're doing. Jade Temple, Perry's first restaurant opening following his move into the hedge fund-backed Rockpool Dining Group, was fairly wobbly off the blocks, both in terms of service and food, but Rosetta has hit the ground running.

Veal tonnato

And some of the best things on the menu are the least expensive. The trippa alla Romana surrenders to the fork, a little more tomato-acidic than would be ideal, but nicely framed by the taste of pecorino and mint. Oh, and it's $19. At first sight pizzette might seem a little bit naff and off-brand for a restaurant like this - like the company is doing R&D on a food-court Rosetta-lite spin off (Rosetta-ette? Nonna Neil's?). But the toppings are smart: a bianca-style with broad beans, say, or another done with smoked garlic sausage from master butcher Pino Tomini Foresti. Sink your teeth into the Inferno, a spicy eight-incher with chilli salumi, a puffy crust and rounds of pickled yellow pepper scattered across it, and your scepticism evaporates. And it's $12.

If you're watching your purse, you could have the $5 cannolo for dessert - small, crisp shell of chocolate pastry piped with mascarpone mousse. But that would mean forgoing the torta di Verona, the thinking person's tiramisù, served here as a creamy wodge of pandoro soaked in amaretto and Marsala with blueberry compote.

Torta di Verona

Barely weeks old, Rosetta already feels like a fixture of the Sydney dining scene - in the best of ways. The size of its menu invites exploration, but its plating is confident enough in its simplicity that it never wants for comfort. The corporate heart of the city might be the last place you'd expect to find a touch of soul, but Rosetta gets it right.


117 Harrington Street, Sydney, (02) 8099 7089,


Cards  AE MC V EFT

Open Lunch daily noon-3pm. Dinner Mon-Sat 6pm-11pm, Sun 6pm-10pm.

Prices Entrées $11-$35, main courses $19-$49, desserts $19-$21

Vegetarian Seven antipasti, two pasta, one main course

Noise Noisy

Wheelchair access Yes

Minus Wine mark-ups

Plus Unfussy, upmarket Italian


117 Harrington Street, Sydney, (02) 8099 7089,


Cards  AE MC V EFT

Open Lunch daily noon-3pm. Dinner Mon-Sat 6pm-11pm, Sun 6pm-10pm.

Prices Entrées $11-$35, main courses $19-$49, desserts $19-$21

Vegetarian Seven antipasti, two pasta, one main course

Noise Noisy

Wheelchair access Yes

Minus Wine mark-ups

Plus Unfussy, upmarket Italian

The Gourmet Traveller podcast

Each fortnight we round up the most interesting characters from the food world for your listening pleasure. We chat to chefs, cooks, authors, bar tenders and baristas - anyone who has something new and interesting to say about the way we like to eat and drink.

Recipe collections

Looking for fresh dinner ideas? Not sure how to make the most out of seasonal produce? Or do you need to plan the perfect party menu? Our recipe collections have you covered.

See more

You might also like...

Momofuku Seiobo

How to sum up Momofuku Seiobo's 12-course meal? Excellent e...

Bang, Sydney restaurant review

Panache could be a watchword for Bang, Surry Hills’ first fo...

Sydney's new cult burger, layer by layer

Sokyo's Chase Kojima's new project is something completely n...

Back to the 1980s at Bennelong

A collection documenting the life of the Sydney Opera House ...

Silvereye to close this August

Chef Sam Miller is heading back to the UK.

Chase Kojima's rice burger bar opens this week

Prepare to hold a new style of burger glory – wrapped in ric...

A Tavola

Sydney is spoilt for choice when it comes to Italian food a...

Bar H

Is it a bar with good food or a restaurant with a good bar?...

Buon Ricordo

Buon Ricordo exudes Italianness. Passion and professionalis...


The Merivale group's homage to the French brasserie is well...

Flying Fish

Here is a restaurant writ large in size, form and aspect - ...

Fratelli Paradiso

Think of Paradiso as a stage, its diners and staff all acto...

Golden Century

There's a view that Golden Century is all about chefs' late...


Hartsyard opened in 2012 when American fare here, beyond me...

Harpoon Harry

"DINE DRINK DANCE" reads the motto on the Harpoon Harry web...